Tips for a First Time Condo Buyer in NYC

Buying a condo in NYC may seem easy, but a first time condo buyer in NYC faces many challenges and pitfalls that can be extremely costly down the road. For example, did you know that both property tax figures and square footages are commonly inflated by listing agents? Or how about the fact that you can get a portion of your buyer agent’s commission back at closing? We’ll discuss tips for a first time condo buyer in NYC that you’ll wish you had known before buying.

A first time condo buyer will save a lot of time by getting pre-approved for a mortgage before starting their search. Doing so will save the buyer lots of time from checking out properties that are out of their price range, and will help the buyer figure out just what their price range is.

After all, why waste a bunch of time narrowing down a list of $5 million properties when your bank will only allow you to borrow 80% on a $2 million property?

This is especially important if you are carrying other debt such as student loans, auto loans or credit card balances.

This other debt will negatively affect your Debt-to-Income Ratio (DTI Ratio) and may cause you to be approved for far less than you had imagined.

A first time condo buyer may know that the services of a buyer’s agent are free since the seller pays the commission; however, a first time condo buyer often won’t know that they can also earn some of the buyer agent’s commission for themselves.

The truth is, the seller typically signs an Exclusive Right to Sell Listing Agreement whereby they agree to pay 6% in commission regardless of how the buyer is found.

In practice, this commission is typically split equally per MLS rules between a buyer’s agent and the seller’s agent. As a result, you should never naively believe that your buyer’s agent is working for you pro bono. They are getting just as much commission as the seller’s agent!

So how can you get some of the buyer agent’s commission back? By signing up for a Hauseit Buyer Closing Credit and working with one of our experienced partner brokers who have discreetly agreed to give you back $20,000 or more at closing.

Everything is negotiable in the NYC real estate market, including who pays what NYC closing costs. In a buyer’s market, sellers and developers will be keen to negotiate and will often offer to take on some of the buyer’s closing costs, such as the NYC Mansion Tax.

If you a buying a new construction home in NYC, it’s even more important to understand that you can negotiate with the sponsor on closing costs. In fact, sponsors and developers are much keener to negotiate on closing costs vs headline listing prices, especially if they have a lot of inventory they need to sell.

The last thing they’ll want to do is to reduce listing prices which will make it harder to sell the rest of their units. As a result, developers will always be more willing to negotiate on non-optical items like closing costs.

Unlike in a re-sale, sponsors typically expect the buyer to pay their NYC and NYS transfer taxes and attorney’s fees in a typical new development purchase. If you don’t know that this is negotiable, you can easily be led to believe that this is just the way that things are done and accept it.

However, an experienced buyer’s agent will tell you that this is all negotiable, especially in a soft real estate market. You can easily make an offer stipulating that you will not be paying any closing costs on the sponsor’s behalf!

One of the biggest mistakes that a first time condo buyer in NYC will make is to not verify the square footage of a property. Even though it’s relatively easy to find the official square footage for a condo unit, many listing agents will inflate the square footages on their listings and protect themselves with a disclaimer saying the figure is simply an estimate.

Keep in mind that there’s no standard for how to measure square feet for real estate in NYC. Some older buildings will be more conservative and only list the interior square footage on their offering plans. However, many new construction buildings will be more aggressive and include wall space¹ and even common areas such as the hallway or elevator in the square footage.

You can easily check a condo’s square footage by looking up the unit’s property tax bills on the NYC Department of Finance website. Look for a statement called “Notice of Property Value” and you’ll see a section where the unit’s square footage is listed, typically on the second page. Keep in mind that the city pulls this data typically from the building’s original condo offering plan, which your lawyer can inspect for you during legal and financial due diligence.

¹We’ve heard many experienced brokers tell us that it’s common to include 50% of shared wall space and 100% of exterior wall space in the square footage. The reasoning is if you combine apartments and knock down the shared wall, you’ll get 100% of the now cleared wall space. In a similar vein, if it’s an exterior wall that is not shared, you should include that in your square footage calculation since no one else is using it. With that said, we’re certain that many others will disagree with this approach, and argue that only interior or even only useable interior square footage should be used.

Most buyers will leave it to their lawyer to make an appointment with the co-op or condo’s managing agent to review the condo board meeting minutes in person. We recommend taking matters into your own hands and going with your attorney when he or she goes to review the board meeting minutes.

After all, since you’ll be the one buying the apartment, wouldn’t it be better for you to also review what the board is discussing at its meetings?

Plus, you’ll get an idea of whether your potential future neighbors and board members are nice, competent people or not.

Don’t take property tax figures provided by the listing agent for granted. There aren’t any strictly enforced rules or standards on how property taxes should be presented in NYC.

Whereas in the Hudson Valley the OneKey MLS will require all property tax figures to be an annual figure before any exemptions or abatements, there are no such rules in NYC.

In the NYC real estate market, property tax figures are typically only required to be monthly.

Properties with tax abatements or exemptions like the 421a Tax Abatement or the 421g Tax Abatement will usually list the reduced property tax figure to account for the abatement, even if the abatement will be expiring the very next year.

So make sure you diligence when the abatement the property has will expire before getting too excited about temporarily low property tax numbers.